The Best Xbox One Games: A Deep Dive into Metacritic’s Top Picks
The Xbox One console endured a challenging launch, facing criticism for its initial policies and perceived lack of exclusive titles. Yet, as the video above perfectly illustrates, Microsoft made significant adjustments, leading to a vibrant library of critically acclaimed experiences. Many people like to joke that “Xbox has no games,” but that couldn’t be further from the truth. This console boasts an impressive collection of titles, both exclusives and multi-platform masterpieces, that have earned high praise from critics and players alike. We’re diving deep into the top 20 best Xbox One games, as determined by their Metacritic scores, to highlight the incredible journey this console took from a rocky start to a gaming powerhouse. These are not just subjective favorites, but games recognized for their outstanding quality and lasting impact.
From expansive open worlds and intense action RPGs to challenging indie platformers and competitive multiplayer experiences, the Xbox One catalog truly offers something for every type of gamer. Imagine if you only ever played the biggest blockbuster titles; you might miss out on hidden gems that push creative boundaries. This list, based on the aggregate scores from professional reviews, ensures we’re looking at games that consistently delivered excellence.
Exploring Critically Acclaimed Xbox One Games (Scores 88-89)
Starting strong, a score of 88 or 89 on Metacritic is nothing short of excellent. These games represent the high bar set for gaming excellence on the Xbox One, often redefining genres or delivering exceptional narrative experiences.
Divinity Original Sin Enhanced Edition (Metascore: 88)
Kicking off our journey is Divinity Original Sin Enhanced Edition, a remastered triumph of a critically acclaimed, fan-funded fantasy RPG from 2014. Originally a PC exclusive, its massive success paved the way for this definitive console version. What makes it special? It revives the classic isometric RPG feel with modern depth. Players navigate a rich, interactive world, engaging in strategic turn-based combat and making choices that genuinely impact the narrative. Imagine a game where you can literally set fire to an oil slick on the ground to create a defensive barrier, or electrify a puddle to stun enemies. The Enhanced Edition refined its visuals, added voice acting, and streamlined the experience for controllers, making it an essential pick for RPG enthusiasts.
Wolfenstein 2: The New Colossus (Metascore: 88)
Step into an alternate 1960s where the Nazi regime conquered the world in Wolfenstein 2: The New Colossus. This sequel to The New Order continues the visceral story of B.J. Blazkowicz as he fights to ignite a second American Revolution. It blends brutal first-person shooting with a compelling, often darkly humorous narrative. The game transports you to iconic U.S. landmarks, reimagined under fascist rule, creating a chillingly effective backdrop for its intense action. The developers truly excelled at creating a sense of desperation and resilience, making every shot fired feel incredibly impactful.
N++ (Metascore: 88)
For those who crave a challenge, N++ delivers. This indie platformer is a masterclass in minimalist design and brutal difficulty. You play as a nimble ninja, navigating intricate levels filled with deadly obstacles. While the premise is simple – get to the exit – the execution requires pixel-perfect timing and relentless precision. It’s the kind of game that might make you want to throw your controller across the room, but the satisfaction of finally clearing a seemingly impossible level is immensely rewarding. This spiritual successor to N+ ramps up the difficulty but maintains that addictive quality of “just one more try.”
Fallout 4 (Metascore: 88)
Bethesda’s Fallout 4, an open-world RPG, landed in late 2015 with immense anticipation. While it faced some criticism for cut features and exaggerated pre-release hype compared to previous entries, it remains a sprawling, immersive adventure in a post-apocalyptic Boston. The game’s lasting appeal is largely thanks to its thriving modding community, which continues to introduce new quests, items, and gameplay enhancements years after its release. Imagine building your own settlements, exploring irradiated ruins, and uncovering the mysteries of a devastated world, all while custom-tailoring your experience with community-created content. It offers hundreds of hours of exploration and character development.
Injustice 2 (Metascore: 89)
DC Comics fans finally got their answer to the classic Marvel vs. Capcom series with Injustice 2. This fighting game, a sequel to the acclaimed Injustice: Gods Among Us, further refines its combat mechanics and expands its roster of iconic heroes and villains. Beyond the tight, combo-driven gameplay, it features a surprisingly deep and engaging story mode that continues the narrative of a fractured DC universe. The gear system, allowing players to customize character appearances and stats, adds another layer of depth, inviting endless personalization and strategic loadouts.
Destiny: The Taken King (Metascore: 89)
Bungie’s ambitious shared-world shooter, Destiny, had a notoriously rocky launch in 2014. However, the release of The Taken King expansion marked a significant turning point. This massive content drop addressed nearly all of the base game’s criticisms, overhauling the story, mission structure, and loot system. While its distribution method was debated, the expansion itself was widely praised for transforming Destiny into the epic space opera it was always meant to be. It delivered a focused narrative, engaging raid content, and a much-needed sense of progression. Players suddenly found themselves deeply invested in the universe, exploring new worlds and unraveling complex alien threats.
Stardew Valley (Metascore: 89)
One of the most unexpectedly popular games on this list is Stardew Valley, a charming farming and life simulation RPG. Released in late 2016, it quickly became a phenomenon, blending the relaxing elements of games like Animal Crossing and classic farm simulators with RPG progression. Players inherit a dilapidated farm and are tasked with revitalizing it, growing crops, raising animals, fishing, mining, and befriending the quirky townsfolk. Its pixel-art style and incredibly calming gameplay loops have made it a go-to for casual gamers and those seeking a peaceful escape. Imagine building your dream farm, cultivating relationships, and discovering hidden secrets at your own pace—it’s a truly wholesome experience.
Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin (Metascore: 89)
The Dark Souls series is synonymous with challenging combat, intricate level design, and deep lore. Dark Souls 2 initially launched in 2014, but it was the 2015 “Scholar of the First Sin” edition for next-gen consoles that truly delivered the definitive experience. This updated version included all previously released DLC, additional content, enhanced multiplayer, and rebalanced enemy placements, presenting a fresh challenge even for veterans. It remained a punishing action RPG, where success comes from learning enemy patterns, mastering dodge rolls, and patiently exploring its vast, interconnected world. Facing a towering boss and finally overcoming it after numerous attempts is a core part of its enduring appeal.
Stepping Up: High-Rated Experiences (Metascores 90-91)
As we move into the 90+ territory, we encounter games that are not just good, but exceptional. These titles often push graphical boundaries, offer groundbreaking gameplay, or deliver unforgettable narratives that resonate long after the credits roll.
NBA 2K17 (Metascore: 90)
The NBA 2K series consistently dominates the basketball simulation genre, much like Madden and FIFA do for football and soccer. NBA 2K17 was no exception, praised for its fun and realistic basketball gameplay, improved visuals, and a host of new features that built upon its predecessors. It delivered an authentic hoops experience, allowing players to live out their basketball fantasies, whether managing a franchise or guiding a created player through a compelling career mode. The yearly improvements, though sometimes incremental, keep the franchise fresh and engaging for its dedicated fanbase.
Dead Cells (Metascore: 90)
Indie darling Dead Cells burst onto the scene in 2018, immediately impressing critics with its unique blend of rogue-like and Metroidvania elements. You take on the role of a “Beheaded,” a collection of cells reanimating a corpse in a sprawling, ever-changing prison. The game challenges you with fast-paced, fluid combat, a massive arsenal of weapons, and a procedural map that ensures every run feels fresh. Death is constant, but progress is made through unlocking permanent upgrades, pushing players to constantly refine their skills and strategies. Imagine a relentless dance of dodging and attacking, where mastering your chosen build is key to surviving its brutal dungeons.
Monster Hunter World (Metascore: 90)
Capcom’s Monster Hunter World was one of the first major triple-A titles of 2018, and it set a high bar for the year. This entry brought the long-running series to a wider global audience without sacrificing its core identity. Players become hunters, tracking and slaying colossal monsters in breathtaking ecosystems. The game is a masterclass in environmental design, with each zone feeling like a living, breathing habitat. The loop of hunting, carving, and crafting new gear to take on even bigger beasts is incredibly addictive. Imagine stalking a majestic Rathalos through ancient forests, coordinating traps with your team, and finally bringing it down after an epic twenty-minute battle – that’s the essence of Monster Hunter World.
Nier: Automata – Become as Gods Edition (Metascore: 90)
Nier: Automata is not just a game; it’s a profound narrative experience disguised as an action RPG. Released in 2017, the Xbox One received the “Become as Gods Edition” in June of that year, which included enhanced visuals, smoother performance, and all DLC bundled into one package. This definitive version perfectly showcased the game’s unique blend of philosophical storytelling, hack-and-slash combat, and bullet-hell mechanics. It explores themes of identity, humanity, and existence through the eyes of androids 2B, 9S, and A2. The game’s multiple endings, each revealing a new layer to its intricate plot, make it an unforgettable journey.
Forza Horizon 3 (Metascore: 91)
Microsoft’s exclusive racing series, Forza Horizon, continually sets the bar for open-world driving experiences. Forza Horizon 3, released in 2016, transported players to the stunning landscapes of Australia. It combines realistic car physics with an accessible, arcade-style feel, allowing both hardcore racing fans and casual players to enjoy the thrill. The visuals are spectacular, showcasing diverse environments from lush rainforests to sandy beaches. Imagine customizing hundreds of vehicles, exploring vast open roads, and participating in exhilarating festivals and races across an entire continent—it’s a petrolhead’s dream and a visual feast.
Overwatch (Metascore: 91)
Blizzard’s Overwatch, a class-based first-person shooter, became a global phenomenon upon its release in May 2016. Its vibrant cast of heroes, each with unique abilities and personalities, captivated millions. The gameplay is easy to learn but incredibly difficult to master, promoting teamwork and strategic play over individual prowess. Whether you prefer to be a damage dealer, a tank, or a support character, there’s always a crucial role to play in leading your team to victory. Imagine a chaotic yet coordinated battle where a perfectly timed ultimate ability can turn the tide of a match—that’s the high-octane excitement of Overwatch.
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (Metascore: 91)
Widely regarded as one of the greatest video games ever created, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt truly deserves its spot among the best Xbox One games. Released in 2015, CD Projekt Red’s epic RPG puts you in the boots of Geralt of Rivia, a monster hunter searching for his adopted daughter, Ciri, amidst a war-torn continent. Its sprawling open world, rich storytelling, complex characters, and impactful choices set a new standard for the genre. Imagine a world where every side quest feels like a mini-saga, every moral decision carries weight, and the lore is so dense it could fill a library. The Witcher 3’s combination of compelling narrative, stunning visuals, and robust gameplay makes it a must-play.
The Zenith of Xbox One Gaming (Metascores 92-97)
These are the absolute pinnacle of critical acclaim on the Xbox One, games that broke barriers, set new benchmarks, and solidified their place in gaming history. They showcase incredible innovation, technical mastery, and storytelling prowess.
What Remains of Edith Finch (Metascore: 92)
What Remains of Edith Finch, released in 2017, is a poignant and visually inventive mystery game. It’s often described as a “walking simulator” due to its focus on exploration and narrative over traditional gameplay mechanics. Players revisit the sprawling, eccentric Finch family home, unraveling the strange curses and tragic stories that befell each family member. Each story segment is presented with unique gameplay mechanics and stylistic flourishes, making it a masterclass in interactive storytelling. Imagine experiencing the final moments of various characters, each presented with a distinct, creative flair that immerses you completely in their fate. It’s a game that stays with you long after you’ve finished it.
Inside (Metascore: 93)
From Playdead, the creators of the beloved indie hit Limbo, came Inside in 2016. This spiritual successor maintained the studio’s signature dark, minimalist aesthetic and haunting atmosphere. It’s a 2.5D puzzle-platformer that tells a wordless, deeply unsettling story through its environments and events. Players control a young boy navigating a desolate, oppressive world, solving challenging environmental puzzles while avoiding grotesque dangers. The game excels at creating a sense of dread and mystery, forcing players to be creative and methodical to survive. Imagine being constantly pursued by unknown forces, with every shadow potentially concealing a threat; Inside is a masterclass in tension and environmental storytelling.
Celeste (Metascore: 94)
Celeste, released in January 2018, is another indie triumph that garnered immense critical praise. This 2D platformer from Matt Makes Games is renowned for its incredibly tight controls, innovative level design, and a surprisingly heartfelt story about overcoming personal struggles. While some gamers found its difficulty challenging, critics celebrated it as a “good kind of difficult,” where every death feels like a learning opportunity rather than a punishment. Imagine chaining together precise jumps, dashes, and wall climbs to navigate treacherous mountainscapes, all while a powerful narrative about anxiety and perseverance unfolds. It’s a beautifully crafted experience that proves platformers can tell profound stories.
Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain (Metascore: 95)
Hideo Kojima’s final major installment in the iconic franchise, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain, sent the series off in a blaze of glory in September 2015. This game redefined stealth action with its expansive open-world environments and unprecedented freedom in mission approach. Players take on the role of Punished “Venom” Snake, building a private army and executing complex infiltration missions. The game was lauded for its visual storytelling, deeply customizable gameplay, and a captivating, if controversial, narrative. Imagine planning your infiltration down to the last detail, choosing your entry point, time of day, and equipment, then executing it with dynamic stealth mechanics. It’s a testament to ambitious game design.
Grand Theft Auto V (Metascore: 97)
Topping our list of the best Xbox One games is none other than Grand Theft Auto V. Originally released in 2013, the Xbox One version arrived later with enhanced visuals and additional features, making the wait absolutely worthwhile. This title quickly became the most financially successful entertainment product of all time, and its enduring popularity is a testament to Rockstar’s incredible support. It offers a sprawling open-world Los Santos, a compelling narrative experienced through three distinct protagonists, and an unparalleled level of detail and interactivity. Imagine seamlessly switching between characters, each with their own story arcs, as you pull off daring heists, explore a vibrant city, and engage in countless side activities. The online component, GTA Online, continues to thrive, offering endless multiplayer fun. Its massive scope, intricate design, and continuous evolution make it a true masterpiece of the generation.
This comprehensive look at the top-rated Xbox One games by Metacritic score truly dispels any notion that the console lacks quality titles. From indie gems that push creative boundaries to blockbuster open-world epics, the Xbox One library offers a rich tapestry of gaming experiences. What’s your favorite Xbox One game of all time?
